NAR Class Action Settlement
3/23/2024NAR SETTLEMENT March 23, 2024
As much as I am loathe to admit it, I have been in real estate since February 1974… yes that is 50 years ago. For 50 years, I can vouch for the fact that, despite what recent media reports would have you believe, real estate commissions have always been negotiable.
Last week the National Association of REALTORS (NAR) settled a historic lawsuit which has fueled wild media reports that suggest NAR has always mandated policies which resulted in real estate commissions being higher than they should be.
In fact, for as long as I have been in real estate, just the opposite has been true. NAR’s education has always pounded into our heads that we must scrupulously avoid any actions that can be construed as price-fixing, or even the hint of price-fixing. NAR has never in the last 50 years (in my personal experience) recommended or suggested commission amounts. Individual brokerage firms have made their own decisions about what commission rate they will charge for the services they provide.
The misleading media reports are suggesting that only now, ostensibly as a result of this settlement, will Buyers be able to negotiate their broker’s compensation. Not true. Buyers have always been able to negotiate what their agent will be paid. I personally have handled many transactions where the buyer negotiated to represent themselves in exchange for a commission reduction which the Seller passed along to the Buyer either as a concession or a price reduction.
Most of us in the Realtor world are stunned by the settlement but are 100% willing to adapt to the new way of doing things, which really won’t be that much different than what most of us have been doing for many years.
The big winners in this settlement? The attorneys.
Sadly, the biggest losers in this settlement are home-buyers. The new rules starting in July will require that Buyers must negotiate their own written agreement with their real estate broker which specifies how and how much their broker will be paid. This will result in many homebuyers having to bring more cash to the table than ever before. Up until now, the Buyer typically needed to have cash for their down payment and closing costs. That amount is usually in the tens of thousands of dollars. Adding another several thousand to the buyer’s upfront cash requirement will put the American Dream that much farther out of reach for the average homebuyer.
Meanwhile, I am suggesting to my Seller clients that they budget for the possibility (and likelihood) that when these rules kick in come July, Buyers will make offers asking the Seller to pay the Buyer’s broker’s fee. The end result will be the same as it has previously been (contrary to the media hype) with the money to pay the Buyer’s broker still coming from the transaction proceeds.
Business as usual… more or less.

#affordablebeachhouse #fractionalshare #buyabeachhouse #oceansideoregon #oregoncoast #beachvacationhome #oceanviewhouse #liveinluxury



